Skip to main content

OER Skepticism

What follows are two questions from and two potential responses to someone who is skeptical about adopting and open educational resource.

Anyone could have posted that information online.

This question surprises me. I understand it as a reflex, but not as an argument that anyone would defend. It's true that OER can be written and published by anyone; however, it is also true that faculty members are experts in their domains and are ultimately responsible for ensuring that the information presented to their students is appropriate and factual. Regardless of an author's academic status or lack thereof their work has the potential to be useful; however, that's up to individual instructors to decide. Adopting OER requires effort on the part of instructors as it would if they were adopting a traditional textbook -perhaps more in order to tailor the OER to their class or make it more thorough. In exchange for their effort, students taking that class forevermore will not have to purchase materials.


OER aren't peer reviewed like most textbooks.


That's not entirely true.  OpenStax textbooks are written by a host of experts much like traditional textbooks and do go through a peer review process. Furthermore over half of the textbooks in the Open Textbook Library, a repository of open textbooks, have undergone peer review (FAQ, 2017). To be included in the Open Textbook Library, books must be "in use at multiple higher educational institutions, or affiliated with a higher education institution, scholarly society, or professional organization." (criteria, 2017) If you are willing to contribute a review of a text in the Open Textbook Library, they have been known to provide stipends in exchange for that effort during workshops and would likely accept a review written by a faculty member at a higher education institution.


Open Textbook Library FAQ. (n.d.). Retrieved October 28, 2017, from https://open.umn.edu/opentextbooks/FAQ.aspx
What about the quality of open textbooks?

Open Textbook Library Submit an Open Textbook. (n.d.). Retrieved October 28, 2017, from https://open.umn.edu/opentextbooks/Submit.aspx
Criteria

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

An Introduction to OER

The term "Open Educational Resources" or OER describe educational materials that include but are not limited to textbooks, videos, quizzes, articles, and websites that provide others the permission to exercise the "five Rs" of the Open Content Definition put forth by David Wiley. The five Rs themselves are ways in which OER can be used that separate them from traditional educational resources. The most trivial argument to be made in favor or OER is that they are free of cost. -freely accessible to everyone; all students and instructors regardless of geography. Retain - the right to make, own, and control copies of the content (e.g., download, duplicate, store, and manage) Reuse - the right to use the content in a wide range of ways (e.g., in a class, in a study group, on a website, in a video) Revise - the right to adapt, adjust, modify, or alter the content itself (e.g., translate the content into another language) Remix - the right to combine the original or rev...
1 comment
Read more

Considerations for Creating OER

Before creating OER, first consider a few things. The specifics of open licenses vary but in general all OER are created in the spirit of reuse. As such, users of OER must be afforded two things in order to make full use of them. -they need the ability and the permission to exercise the 5 Rs. First, the 5 Rs themselves: Retain -   the right to   make, own, and control . . . Reuse -   the right to   use content . . . Revise -   the right to   adapt, adjust, modify, or alter . . . Remix -   the right to   . . . make something new Redistribute -   the right to   share copies . . . of OER. These points are addressed by the license applied to a work. The license should be of the "open" variety, Creative Commons licenses, and others such as the GNU Free Documentation License address the 5 Rs. Though these are common and practical, neither of these examples are as open as no license at all -putting your work in the Public Domain. On...
Post a Comment
Read more

Capstone Project Proposal

As my capstone project in the SPARC Leadership Program I will pursue the conversion of a class that spans multiple sections, taught by several instructors from assigning a costly resource to using OER. I understand that textbooks used in this type of class are picked not by individual instructors rather by a decision-making entity like a department chair or a committee. Through an iterative, systematic approach I hope to convince this entity to switch from using costly traditional resources to OER for use in classes taking place in 2019. Relationship building and needs assessments will be performed in the first half of 2018. Maintaining those relationships, the remainder of 2018 will consist of work done to modify or supplement an existing resource to fit the needs of the body of instructors who will be using it. It is worth mentioning that I do plan on targeting Calculus classes. At this stage I have Calculus in mind because of the existing relationship the OER team of which I am a ...
Post a Comment
Read more